The Washington Post
BRIDGEWATER, N.J. — Mounting signs of global economic distress this week have alarmed President Trump, who is worried that a downturn could imperil his reelection, even as administration officials acknowledge that they have not planned for a possible recession.
Trump is banking on a strong economy to win a second term in 2020, and in recent weeks he has impulsively lashed out at the Federal Reserve, pressured Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin to label China a “currency manipulator,” and unexpectedly delayed tariffs on Chinese imports out of fear they could depress holiday retail sales.
Yet despite gyrations in the U.S. stock market and economic slowdowns in other countries, officials in the White House, at the Treasury Department and throughout the administration are planning no new steps to attempt to stave off a recession. Rather, Trump’s economic advisers have been delivering the president upbeat assessments in which they argue that the domestic economy is stronger than many forecasters are making it out to be.
In turn, Trump has sought to use his Twitter pulpit to drown out negative indicators. On Thursday, he promoted the U.S. economy as “the Biggest, Strongest and Most Powerful Economy in the World,” and, citing growth in the retail sector, predicted that it would only get stronger. He also accused the news media of “doing everything they can to crash the economy because they think that will be bad for me and my re-election.”
Privately, however, the president has sounded anxious and apprehensive. From his golf club in New Jersey, where he is vacationing this week, Trump has called a number of business leaders and financial executives to sound them out — and they have provided him a decidedly mixed analysis, according to two people familiar with the discussions who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the conversations were confidential.
Trump has a somewhat conspiratorial view, telling some confidants that he distrusts statistics he sees reported in the news media and that he suspects many economists and other forecasters are presenting biased data to thwart his reelection, according to one Republican close to the administration who was briefed on some of the conversations.
“He’s rattled,” this Republican said. “He thinks that all the people that do this economic forecasting are a bunch of establishment weenies — elites who don’t know anything about the real economy and they’re against Trump.”
President Trump speaks to reporters before boarding Air Force One in Morristown, N.J. From his golf club in New Jersey, Trump has called a number of business leaders and financial executives to sound them out.
Trump has relentlessly bludgeoned Fed Chair Jerome H. Powell over interest rates and has told aides and allies that he would be a scapegoat if the economy goes south.
The stock market has slumped in recent weeks because of a number of factors. The U.S.-China trade war has become increasingly acrimonious and is affecting both economies. Germany and the United Kingdom appear to be nearing a recession. Argentina’s stock market has crashed. Meanwhile, a key predictor of future recessions in the bond market — an inverted “yield curve” — was triggered this week, which spooked investors even more.
White House officials said the fundamentals of the U.S. economy remain very strong, citing low unemployment, high productivity, low inflation and strong retail sales. They said the recent turbulence may be connected to problems in other countries, and that there is no reason to recalibrate the administration’s approach, which has relied on low taxes, deregulation and low energy costs.
“I think it’s right to look at what is actually happening,” National Economic Council Director Larry Kudlow said in an interview. “To me, it’s a pretty good story. Nobody likes to see market volatility. I get that. You get bears coming out of the woodwork. I get that. But we’ve been through that before.”
The administration’s economic message has been muddled, however, causing more uncertainty. While Kudlow has been expressing public optimism that a deal could be reached with China, senior trade adviser Peter Navarro has been vigorously defending Trump’s tough tactics and promising a huge economic rebound later this year. Mnuchin, meanwhile, has been largely absent from public view since the trade discussions with China worsened several weeks ago.
In the past, world leaders have come together to try to assure the public about a unified approach to confronting global economic turmoil. But Trump has threatened to slap tariffs on Japanese and German cars and on French wine, and has encouraged newly minted British Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s call to withdraw the United Kingdom from the European Union, even if it means a violent breakup that threatens the economic standing of multiple countries.
Traders and financial professionals work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange at the opening bell Thursday.
Lawrence H. Summers, a former treasury secretary and National Economic Council director who helped lead the Obama administration’s efforts to end the Great Recession a decade ago, said no president is immune to a recession and the government ought always to be planning for and guarding against one.
“When the economy turns down, one of the important resources we have is policymakers’ credibility,” Summers said. “Ludicrous forecasts and economically illiterate statements have dissipated the credibility of the president’s economic team.”
Referring specifically to Trump’s actions, Summers added, “It’s banana republic standard to deny the statistics, bash the central bank, try to push the currency down and lash out at foreign countries.”
Trump has been closely managing his administration’s moves. Two weeks ago, he exerted immense pressure on Mnuchin to label China as a “currency manipulator,” a move the treasury secretary had repeatedly resisted because China’s currency moves did not meet the Treasury’s established criteria, three people with direct knowledge of the push said.
Administration officials are not actively planning for a recession because they do not believe one will occur, and they worry that making such plans would validate a negative narrative about the economy and precipitate a crash, according to people involved in internal discussions.
Trump is significantly more concerned about an economic downturn than his top advisers, according to a senior White House official. Although the economy sometimes has come up in senior staff meetings, the focus of those discussions has been on how best to promote positive trends rather than how to prepare for a downturn, a senior administration official said.
Despite recent declines in the industrial and agricultural segments caused by the trade war, business leaders are not yet predicting doomsday, said Kathryn Wylde, who leads the Partnership for New York City, which includes CEOs of many of the country’s biggest companies. “People aren’t seeing a dramatic downturn coming unless something really dramatic happens with China,” Wylde said.
Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren (Mass.) speaks at a campaign event Wednesday in Franconia, N.H. She issued a policy statement last month about how to stop a coming economic crash.
Still, some of Trump’s Democratic challengers have focused on the possibility of a recession. Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts issued a policy statement last month titled, “The Coming Economic Crash and How to Stop It.”
In it, she diagnoses problems in what she calls “our precarious economy” — including record auto loan debt and rising living costs — and writes, “warning lights are flashing.” She also lays out ideas to strengthen manufacturing, reduce household debt and use existing oversight authority to more closely monitor risks from corporate debt.
“She got to the point where she was saying, ‘There’s enough troubling signs that I want to put my case out there,’ ” Warren campaign policy adviser Bharat Ramamurti said.
Former vice president Joe Biden also has had a sharp focus on the economic anxieties of middle-class Americans and has touted his partnership with President Barack Obama to steer the country out of the economic collapse with a stimulus package and other measures.
Trump has been thinking about the economy through the prism of his reelection campaign. He is cognizant of public and private polling that consistently has registered his approval rating on handling the economy higher than it is overall or on any other issue. To that end, Trump’s political advisers believe the key to his reelection is a strong economy.
“President Trump gets to run on jobs have come back, wages are up, unemployment at record lows for Hispanic, African American, Asian, women,” Republican National Committee Chairwoman Ronna McDaniel said Thursday on Fox News Channel. “He has pushed our economy into full gear and he’s doing things that are making lives better for the American people.”
Federal Reserve Chair Jerome H. Powell has been sharply criticized by President Trump over interest rates.
Some conservatives who have previously praised Trump’s economic policy have soured on his approach to trade, however.
“The president doesn’t understand the basics of international economics, and his erratic behavior is likely slowing business investment, working against his signature corporate tax cuts, and hurting his own reelection chances,” said Michael Strain, an economist at the right-leaning American Enterprise Institute.
Josh Holmes, a longtime adviser to Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), said, “This president is in a much stronger position for reelection than it is commonly believed if the economy holds. And if it doesn’t, the inverse is true.”
Public support for incumbent presidents and their party historically has collapsed during recessions, as occurred in 2008, when John McCain failed to persuade voters to keep the White House in Republican hands.
Democratic pollster Peter Hart said Trump could be at heightened risk because survey data show some voters overlook opposition to Trump’s leadership style and support him largely because of the strong economy.
“This president is so polarizing and off-putting to so many voters that he is dependent upon the good economic numbers to sustain his style,” Hart said. “When you start to hit an economic downturn, there’s no personal element that sustains him.”
But analysts explained that it is difficult to make any predictions, considering Trump has defied the laws of political gravity before.
“A strong economy helps a president running for reelection; a weak economy hurts him,” Republican pollster Whit Ayres said. “That’s a standard truth in the history of polling. But because so much of his support comes from his cultural messaging, a weaker economy may not hurt him as much as it would hurt a more traditional president.”
Paletta reported from Washington and Dawsey from Manchester, N.H. Annie Linskey, Toluse Olorunnipa and Matt Viser in Washington contributed to this report.